Squat Or Leg Press : Which Wins?

Squats and leg press are two of the most productive leg builders in existence.

I’d also put hack squats right up there due to their global trauma effect, but if we’re talking sheer mass and strength development, squats and leg press have earned their reputation.

Both allow you to generate serious leverage, stimulate high-threshold motor units, and force progressive overload.

That combination is why they work, and why they’ve been staples in my training and in the Health Kik programs for years.

The question isn’t whether they work – it’s which delivers more impact, and when.

Table of Contents

Leg Press

The leg press has always been one of my favorite compound movements for legs because it suits my biomechanics extremely well. If I’m in an 8-12 heavy grind range or pushing 50-rep DTP sets, the leg press is always in rotation. It’s a fundamental part of my quad development.

The biggest advantage over squats is the lower technical demand.

The machine offers form support, which reduces risk for beginners and protects fatigued lifters who can no longer stabilize under a free bar.

That doesn’t mean you can’t get hurt – plenty of lifters load the machine with sloppy range, poor tempo, and locked knees.

If you respect the form, avoid locking out, control the negative, and stay within a safe range of motion, it becomes a much safer high-output tool for most people.

If you feel your lower back rounding at the bottom, that’s often due to hip flexor tightness and poor lumbar stability.

Don’t lower the sled to the point where lumbar rounding occurs because that transfers unwanted stress into the spine instead of the thighs. Hip mobility work pays off here.

Squat

The barbell squat is more complex than the leg press. When you get it right, the squat is an incredible exercise.

But because it’s more technical, more things can go wrong. Many lifters obsess over depth and end up rounding their spine, collapsing at the knees, or shifting force into joints instead of muscle. That’s poor risk-to-reward.

My philosophy with squats has evolved.

I’ve gone very heavy in the past, working up to 7-plate squats, but today I emphasize controlled negatives, tension, and mechanical consistency over chasing weight.

With this approach you can often use less load, maintain more muscle tension, and still get outstanding hypertrophy.

A common mobility limitation is ankle dorsiflexion. If your heels lift during the squat, placing small plates under the heels is an immediate fix.

Long-term, work on ankle mobility so the fix becomes unnecessary.

Which One Wins?

Both work. Both deserve a consistent place in a serious leg program. They complement each other more than they compete.

If you want maximum load tolerance, metabolic stress, and lower technical demands – the leg press wins.
If you want neuromuscular demand, stabilizer recruitment, athletic carryover, and raw movement skill – the squat wins.

I program both frequently in the Health Kik plans because they accelerate results not just in size but in caloric expenditure and hormonal response.

Heavy compound lower-body movements stimulate growth hormone, improve total-body strength, and drive metabolic demand far beyond the legs alone.

The best approach for building serious leg mass isn’t choosing one over the other.

It’s stacking both strategically based on your training phase and biomechanics.